Circular No. 90/2010/TT-BTC dated June 16, 2010 of the Ministry of Finance guiding 2011 state budget estimation

THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE

Circular No. 90/2010/TT-BTC of June 16, 2010, guiding 2011 state budget estimation

Pursuant to the Government’s Decree No. 60/2003/ND-CP of June 6, 2003, detailing and guiding the State Budget Law;

Pursuant to the Government’s Decree No. 118/2008/ND-CP of November 27, 2008, defining the functions, tasks, powers and organizational structure of the Ministry of Finance;

Pursuant to the Prime Minister’s Directive No. 854/CT-TTg of June 11, 2010, on socio-economic development planning and state budget estimation for 2011;

The Ministry of Finance guides the evaluation of 2010 state budget task performance and 2011 state budget estimation as follows:

Chapter I

EVALUATION OF 2010 STATE BUDGET TASK PERFORMANCE

Article 1. General provisions

1. Bases for evaluation of the 2010 state budget tasks:

- The 2010 state budget tasks passed by the National Assembly in Resolution No. 37/2009/QH12 on 2010 state budget estimation, and the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 1908/QD-TTg of November 19, 2009, on assignment of 2010 state budget estimates.

- The Government’s executive documents, including Resolution No. 03/NQ-CP of January 15, 2010, on major solutions to directing and conducting the implementation of the 2010 socio-economic development plan and state budget estimates; and Resolution No. 18/NQ-CP of April 6, 2010, on solutions to stabilizing the macro-economy, preventing high inflation and reaching an economic growth rate of around 6.5% in 2010.

- The Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 224/2009/TT-BTC of November 26, 2009, stipulating the implementation of 2010 state budget estimates.

- Documents of ministries, central agencies and localities directing the implementation of resolutions of the National Assembly, the Government and People’s Councils on socio-economic development and the state budget for 2010.

- Performance of state budget tasks in the first 6 months of 2010; solutions for implementation in the last 6 months of the year.

2. Together with performing the 2010 state budget tasks, ministries, central agencies and provincial-level People’s Committees shall review and evaluate the performance of state budget tasks during 2006-2010 and 2001-2010 to provide a basis for formulating the 2011-2015 five-year plan and 2011-2020 ten-year strategy.

3. Based on evaluations of the performance of the 2010 state budget tasks and implementation of state budget revenues and expenditures and other related policies and regimes applicable in 2006-2010; and the implementation of conclusions and proposals of inspection and audit agencies, ministries, central agencies and localities shall proactively amend and supplement or propose specific amendments and supplements to these policies and regimes; and make proposals relating to the guidance, direction and organization of state budget task performance to the Ministry of Finance and concerned ministries and agencies for prompt study, amendment and supplementation or submission to competent authorities for timely amendment and supplementation.

Article 2. Evaluation of state budget revenue collection in 2010

Based on state budget revenues collected in the first 6 months of 2010, to evaluate the collection of state budget revenues in the whole year which should exceed by at least over 5% of the estimates decided by the National Assembly and assigned by the Prime Minister (excluding revenues from crude oil and land use levies). During evaluation, to concentrate on the following major contents:

1. To assess and analyze economic impacts and impacts of economic restructuring on the collection of 2010 state budget revenues: Production, business and export-import activities of enterprises in localities; fulfillment of production and sale targets for major products; production costs, sale prices and profits; to take into account new investment projects and expanded or intensive investment projects and projects whose tax grace period has expired; performance of land-related planning and finance tasks; real estate trading transactions; and operation of the securities market.

2. To assess and analyze impacts on state budget revenues of the tax payment extension for enterprises under the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 16/2009/QD-TTg of January 21, 2009; Decision No. 58/2009/QD-TTg of April 16, 2009, promulgating tax solutions to stimulating investment and consumption demands, preventing economic decline and remove difficulties for enterprises; and Decision No. 12/2010/QD-TTg of February 12, 2010, extending enterprise income tax payment periods to further remove difficulties for enterprises, contributing to promoting 2010 economic development; and the administration of export-import policies, including tax adjustments to reduce trade deficit and raw material exports, and tax rate adjustments to implement international commitments.

3. To assess 2010 tax debts and their settlement: To clearly determine tax debts up to December 31, 2009, and estimate tax debts arising in 2010 to be collected in 2010. To fully and accurately calculate tax debts and classify them according to the criteria defined in the tax debt administration process. To propose measures to completely settle tax debts.

4. To assess the coordination among concerned levels and branches in managing state budget revenues, inspecting, examining and controlling tax debt collection and fighting loss, smuggling and trade frauds; and in controlling prices; to report on the number of subjects already examined and inspected in the first six months of 2010 and the estimated number for the whole year; the tax amount proposed for retrospective collection through tax inspection and examination; the tax amount proposed for retrospective collection by the State Audit of Vietnam and the Government Inspectorate and the estimated amount to be collected into the state budget in the year. To propose solutions to promoting coordination in, and raising effectiveness of, these activities.

5. To assess the value-added tax declaration and refund; to estimate the tax amount to be refunded in the year and the amount already refunded in the first 6 months of 2010; clearly analyzing reasons for increased or decreased tax refunds against the previous year.

6. To evaluate impacts of the implementation of tax policies promulgated, amended and supplemented in 2009 and 2010 on collected tax revenues.

7. Through the organization of tax collection, to propose adjustments to collection mechanisms and policies (if any).

Article 3. Evaluation of development investment spending

1. To evaluate the allocation and disbursement of capital construction investment funds in 2010:

a/ To evaluate the allocation and assignment of capital construction investment spending estimates in 2010:

- To evaluate the arrangement and allocation of funds and assignment of capital construction investment spending estimates to projects and works in 2010 (including state budget funds, lottery revenues and government bond funds), especially for important and urgent works and projects to be implemented on time and works and projects to be completed in 2010; to evaluate the allocation of funds in line with development objectives of ministries and branches, ensuring sufficient funds for projects having completed investment procedures according to their implementation schedules.

- To evaluate the time of allocation and assignment of plans to investors. To concurrently evaluate conformity with assigned targets in terms of total investment, structure of domestic and foreign funds, and structure of economic industries.

- To evaluate the allocation of official development assistance (ODA) funds, including arrangement of domestic and overseas funds.

- To evaluate the allocation of funds to pay debts for state budget-funded capital construction investment.

- To evaluate the recovery of advanced state budget funds (according to the principles set forth in Clause 4, Article 1 of Decision No. 1908/QD-TTg of November 19, 2009, on assignment of 2010 state budget estimates) to refund state budget advances under regulations.

b/ To evaluate the review and rearrangement of capital construction investment spending plans under the Government’s Resolution No. 18/NQ-CP of April 6, 2010, on solutions to stabilizing the macro-economy, preventing high inflation and reaching an economic growth rate of around 6.5% in 2010, focusing on:

- Review of investment projects with state budget funds, funds of state budget origin and government bond funds in order to channel funds for important and urgent projects to be completed in 2010.

- Use of funds advanced in 2010 for investment in important and urgent projects and works.

- Examination of investment and investment capital use and management in ministries, central agencies, localities and state economic groups, corporations and enterprises.

c/ To evaluate capital construction investment spending in 2010:

- To generally evaluate the implementation of the 2010 capital construction investment plan, covering the value of the volume implemented by the end of the second quarter of 2010, funds disbursed by the end of the second quarter of 2010 (including payment for completed volumes and advanced investment funds), estimated volume to be implemented and funds to be disbursed by December 31, 2010, and the end of the fiscal year 2010; enclosed with detailed appendices on each project with statistics on approved total investment, funds for accumulative payment up to the fulfillment of the 2009 plan and the 2010 capital plan according to the above contents.

- To evaluate the implementation of ODA-funded programs and projects; allocation of domestic funds to ODA projects under commitment; and the ODA and domestic fund disbursement progress.

- To evaluate the capacity to disburse capital construction investment funds in 2010 from the state budget, government bonds, land use levies and lottery revenues.

d/ To calculate and assess outstanding debts for capital construction investment volumes and their settlement; to propose solutions to completely settling outstanding debts; to evaluate capital construction investment efficiency in 2010 and previous years; to analyze problems, causes and solutions.

e/ To evaluate the settlement of completed investment projects, clearly specifying the number of completed projects remaining unsettled under regulations by the end of June 2010, and the estimated number of these projects by the end of 2010; and the time of completion of these projects, causes and solutions.

f/ To evaluate the advance of funds and recovery and payment of advanced funds balanced at the State Treasury under the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 49/2005/TT-BTC of June 9, 2005, for implementation of infrastructure investment projects and works that are able to generate incomes for repayment of advanced funds approved by competent authorities in order to attract investment from domestic and overseas economic organizations.

2. To evaluate development support spending in 2010:

- Provision of state preferential credit, credit for poor households and social policy beneficiaries, and credit for students (credit provision results, outstanding loans, deposit saving interest rates, amounts arising from interest difference offset).

- Lending for policy implementation (preferential loans for ethnic minority households meeting with special difficulties, poor households building houses, poor households in the Mekong river delta developing production and business, and projects under programs on canal consolidation, rural roads, aquaculture infrastructure and craft village infrastructure).

- Implementation of policies on support for trade promotion, investment and tourism; and policies on support for public product and service suppliers.

- Implementation of 2010 state reserves: Quantities of goods purchased, distributed and granted free (with details on types, quantities and values); state reserves available by December 31, 2010; capacity to respond to incidents.

Article 4. Evaluation of regular spending

1. To evaluate the implementation of state budget estimates in the first six months of 2010 and estimate the whole year implementation (allocation, assignment and withdrawal of state budget estimates; transfer and spending reduction of funds which cannot be allocated to other programs and tasks) according to each target and task assigned by the State to ministries, central agencies, localities and units in 2010. To evaluate the performance of important tasks and major programs and projects of each ministry, branch, domain and locality; to report on difficulties and problems and propose solutions.

2. To report on thrift practice in regular spending, specifically the reduction of unnecessary expenses such as those on conferences, festivals and unnecessary overseas work trips. On that basis, to concentrate funds on newly arising tasks, especially social security tasks and production and export incentives under law.

3. To evaluate results of and difficulties and problems arising in the implementation of spending mechanisms, policies and regimes in 2010 for the performance of tasks of ministries, central agencies, localities and units, paying attention to thoroughly evaluating the implementation of the following mechanisms and policies:

- Social security policies, concentrating on policies under the Government’s Decree No. 67/2007/ND-CP of April 13, 2007, on support for social security beneficiaries, and the Government’s Decree No. 13/2010/ND-CP of February 27, 2010, amending and supplementing a number of articles of Decree No. 67/2007/ND-CP; and policies for poor households and households living just below the poverty line, ethnic minority people, people in areas with special difficulties such as the program on support for quick and sustainable poverty reduction in 62 poor districts, housing support for poor households; state policies for households living just below the poverty line and students to be covered by health insurance; support of farm and residential land, housing and daily-life water for poor ethnic minority households meeting with financial difficulties; unemployment insurance policies; support for prevention, control and consequence remedy of diseases, natural disasters and floods, and famine relief.

- The Government’s Decree No. 130/2005/ND-CP of October 17, 2005, on autonomy in and accountability for the use of payrolls and administration funds. To evaluate the implementation of autonomy and accountability for task performance and organization of apparatus, payrolls and finance by public non-business units under the Government’s Decree No. 43/2006/ND-CP of April 25, 2006, and Decree No. 115/2005/ND-CP of September 5, 2005, and the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 1926/QD-TTg of November 20, 2009.

4. To evaluate the implementation of the Government’s Resolution No. 05/2005/NQ-CP of April 18, 2005, promoting the socialization of educational, healthcare, cultural and physical training and sports activities, and the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 39/2008/QD-TTg of March 14, 2008, promulgating the Regulation on bidding, order placement and assignment of the task to provide state-funded non-business services; the Government’s Decree No. 69/2008/ND-CP of May 30, 2008, on policies to encourage the socialization of educational, vocational, healthcare, cultural, sports and environmental activities in branches and domains; the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 1466/QD-TTg of October 10, 2008, promulgating the detailed list on types, criteria, sizes and standards of establishments engaged in the socialization of educational, training, vocational, healthcare, cultural, sports and environmental activities, paying attention to evaluating and analyzing general resources and structures of social resources for investment in the development of branches and domains, mobilization of social resources for development of branches and domains; problems, causes and solutions in the upcoming time to effectively mobilize social resources to develop branches and domains.

5. To evaluate the implementation of administrative procedure reforms under Project 30 in the management of the 2010 state budget; specifying problems, causes and solutions.

Article 5. Evaluation of the implementation of national target programs, Program 135 (phase II) and 5-million-ha forestation project

1. To evaluate the allocation and assignment of spending estimates for target programs and projects in 2010. Based on assigned spending estimates and implementation progress, ministries and agencies managing national target programs and projects shall assume the prime responsibility for, and coordinate with ministries, central agencies and localities in, reviewing and evaluating the effectiveness of these programs and projects in 2006-2010. On that basis, they shall propose lists, objectives and contents of national target programs and projects in 2011-2015, set scope, contents, principles and criteria for fund allocation, appraisal process, and mechanisms to manage, monitor and evaluate national target programs and projects, and submit them to competent authorities for consideration and decision, providing a basis for implementation from 2011.

2. For domestic-and foreign-funded national target programs, to thoroughly evaluate the disbursement of foreign funds (advantages, difficulties, causes and solutions).

Article 6. Evaluation of the implementation of wage reforms

1. To report on the approval and determination of funds needed for implementing wage reforms.

2. To evaluate the implementation of financial measures to create sources for implementing wage reforms from saving 10% of regular spending (excluding salaries and amounts of salary nature); 35-40% of revenues retained under regulations; and 50% of increased local budget revenues (excluding land use levies) in 2010 and 2007-2010; to determine the previous year’s unused sources under regulations (after allocating sufficient funds to guarantee the minimum wage level of VND 730,000/month in 2010) to be carried forward to 2011 (if any) to continue creating sources for implementing wage reforms (with tables of specific statistics).

Article 7. Some particular points in evaluating the performance of the 2010 state budget tasks by provinces and centrally run cities:

In addition to the above requirements, the following contents should be evaluated:

1. Local solutions and measures for administering local budgets to guarantee local budget spending estimates as decided by competent authorities.

2. Local demands and resources for development; mobilization of local financial resources to perform local socio-economic development tasks.

3. Implementation of policies and regimes under the Prime Minister’s Decisions No. 24/2008/QD-TTg, No. 25/2008/QD-TTg, No. 26/2008/QD-TTg, No. 27/2008/QD-TTg, and No. 113/2009/QD-TTg of September 11, 2009, amending and supplementing a number of articles of Decisions No. 24/2008/QD-TTg, No. 25/2008/QD-TTg, No. 26/2008/QD-TTg, and No. 27/2008/QD-TTg, promulgating a number of mechanisms and policies to support socio-economic development for provinces in the northern central and coastal central regions, the Central Highlands, the Mekong rirver delta and the northern midland and mountainous region up to 2010; the program to support farm and residential land, housing and daily-life water for poor ethnic minority households meeting with financial difficulties (Program 134), the program on socio-economic development for mountainous, deep-lying and remote communes meeting with special difficulties (Program 135-phase II); the Government’s Resolution No. 30a/2008/NQ-CP of December 27, 2008, on the program to support quick and sustainable poverty reduction for 62 poor districts; and policies on housing support for poor households under the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 167/2008/QD-TTg of December 12, 2008.

4. Allocation of budget spending to implement state mechanisms and policies for socio-economic development and poverty reduction such as health insurance policies for the poor and ethnic minority people and under-6 children, support for people living just below the poverty line to enjoy health insurance, unemployment insurance policies, policies in support of fishermen and social security beneficiaries, fund allocation for planning work in localities.

5. Budget allocation (including targeted central budget supports for local budgets, if any) and use of reserves for security and defense; prevention, control and remedy of consequences of natural disasters and diseases of humans, cattle, poultry and crops.

6. Implementation of policies on irrigation fee exemption in localities; exemption from contributions under the Prime Minister’s Directive No. 24/2007/CT-TTg of November 1, 2007, increasingly redressing the implementation of the law on charges and fees and policies to raise and use public contributions.

7. Spending of land use levy revenues on investment in local infrastructure works, land measuring, cadastral dossier compilation, grant of land use right certificates and allocation and formation of land development funds under the Government’s Decree No. 69/2009/ND-CP of August 13, 2009.

8. Collection of lottery revenues, allocation and use of this revenue source for social welfare in localities.

9. Fund raising for infrastructure investment (including fund raising and allocation for payment of principal and interest by June 30, 2010) under Clause 3, Article 8 of the State Budget Law, including outstanding debts at the beginning of the year, amounts raised during the year, due debts, estimated outstanding debts by December 31, 2010 (for Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City, evaluation of investment fund raising under their particular finance-budget mechanisms).

10. Implementation of programs on canal consolidation, rural road building, craft village infrastructure and aquaculture infrastructure (including implementation results, payment of principal and interest due);

11. On the basis of evaluation of the implementation of the 2010 socio-economic plan and state budget, evaluation of the implementation of the socio-economic development plan and state budget in 2006-2010 against the objectives set by resolutions of local party congresses, concentrating on evaluation of achievements, limitations and causes in order to plan 2011-2015 five-year development.

Chapter II

2011 STATE BUDGET ESTIMATION

Article 8. Objectives and principles

1. The 2011 state budget estimates will be made together with the implementation of the Resolution of the XIth Party Congress, the 2011-2015 five-year socio-economic development and finance-budget plans, the 2011-2020 ten-year socio-economic development and finance strategies, being significant in gathering a momentum for quick and sustainable growth for the entire period, raising people’s life quality to a higher level. 2011 state budget estimation should clearly set objectives for promoting quick and sustainable growth and raising  state management effectiveness by implementing appropriate incentive policies to encourage and channel resources for development investment, concentrating resources for economic restructuring toward increased efficiency and competitiveness, quick and sustainable development, increased level and ratio of state budget investment in humans, implementing social security policies, firmly maintaining defense and security and guaranteeing national financial security.

2. The 2011 state budget revenues shall be estimated:

a/ On the basis of closely following investment and production and business development forecasts; complying with policies and regimes; properly and fully calculating state budget revenues of enterprises, organizations and individuals arising in 2011, paying attention to revenues arising in 2010 which are permitted for extended payment and revenues from investment projects whose tax grace period has expired.

b/ Actively, stably and feasibly with revenues accounting for over 23% of GDP, with tax and charge revenues accounting for over 21% of GDP, and domestic revenue estimates of the whole country (excluding revenues from crude oil and land use levies) growing at least 17-19% on average over 2010 estimated revenues (excluding factors caused by tax payment extension in 2009 and 2010).

c/ On the basis of working out measures and specifying roadmaps to settle tax debts; fight tax loss, evasion and contraband and trade frauds; increasing inspection and examination, and detecting and promptly handling violations.

3. Bases for 2011 state budget spending estimation:

State budget estimates shall be made based on criteria and norms on allocation of the 2011 state budget (the first year of the new budget stabilization period); current budget spending policies and regimes and funds needed to achieve important objectives and implement major tasks and strategies of the country set for 2011 and 2011-2015. On that basis:

a/ Based on the system of criteria and norms on 2011 budget allocation under the Prime Minister’s decision, spending regimes and norms and their assigned tasks, ministries and central agencies managing branches and domains and provincial-level People’s Committees shall make 2011 budget spending estimates within the examination codes of 2011 budget spending estimates notified by the Ministry of Finance (particularly, spending from overseas funding sources shall be estimated in detail based on the disbursement progress of projects taking loans and grants) by domain (including spending from state budget balancing sources and from revenues retained under regulations), major spending tasks (with priority order) in accordance with current law and assurance of thrift practice and waste combat right from the estimation stage.

b/ When estimating state budget spending, ministries, central agencies and localities shall proactively estimate sufficient funds to implement promulgated mechanisms and policies and newly arising tasks. For regimes, policies and tasks promulgated in the course of estimation, budget estimates shall be made under the guidance of competent agencies. Ministries, central agencies and localities that, upon budget estimation and assignment, fail to estimate sufficient funds under regulations to perform spending tasks may not receive additional funds from the reserve source for such spending tasks.

c/ When proposing, amending and supplementing policies and regimes in the course of 2011 state budget estimation, ministries, central agencies and localities should conduct surveys to precisely identify the number of beneficiaries and estimate funding needs; integrate policies and regimes to be revised or promulgated with current ones and coordinate with finance agencies in calculating and ensuring sufficient fund allocations for implementation before submitting these policies and regimes to competent authorities for promulgation.

d/ To continue rearranging expenditures in an economical and efficient manner to raise the efficiency of budget investment funds in order to promote quick and sustainable growth, maintain a stable macro-economy and guarantee social security, order and safety; to ensure funds for development of education and training, science and technology, healthcare, culture and environmental protection under resolutions of the Party and the National Assembly; to increase state reserves to proactively prevent, control and remedy consequences of natural disasters and epidemics; to allocate funds to continue wage reforms.

4. Ministries and central agencies shall estimate budget revenues and expenditures, proactively explain in detail bases and grounds for their estimation by implementing unit and important spending task (bases, policies, regimes, implementation results, levels of spending estimate allocations in 2011 and subsequent years) and submit them to the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Planning and Investment for summarization and reporting to the Prime Minister.

5. To balance the state budget and budget of each locality in an active, healthy and steady manner, ensuring national financial security and budget safety for each locality.

Article 9. The 2011 state budget revenue estimation

1. Domestic revenue estimates:

When estimating local state budget revenues, localities shall base themselves on analyses and forecasts of economic growth and restructuring which raise 2011 production capacity for each economic sector, industry and domain of revenues, local key economic institutions and sum up all sources of revenues arising in their localities (including budget revenues of communes, wards and townships). When estimating 2011 state budget revenues, they shall base on full evaluation of 2009 implementation results; targets and realization capacity for 2010 and notified examination codes of 2011 spending estimates. Spending estimation must properly and fully take into account each domain of revenues and each type of tax under the tax law and collecting regimes, paying attention to newly promulgated, amended and supplemented regimes and policies below:

a/ Enterprise income tax: To comply with the Government’s Decree No. 53/2010/ND-CP of May 19, 2010, defining areas entitled to investment and tax incentives for administrative units established upon the Government’s adjustment of administrative boundaries; the Ministry of Finance’s documents such as Circular No. 177/2009/TT-BTC of September 10, 2009, guiding the determination of taxable incomes for exchange rate differences of payable debts in foreign currencies; Circular No. 201/2009/TT-BTC of October 15, 2009, guiding the handling of exchange rate differences in enterprises; Circular No. 203/2009/TT-BTC of October 20, 2009, guiding regimes on management, use and depreciation of fixed assets; Decision No. 3027/QD-BTC of December 3, 2009, correcting Circular No. 130/2008/TT-BTC of December 26, 2008; Circular No. 06/2010/TT-BTC of January 13, 2010, guiding enterprise income tax for sale of golf-course tickets and membership; and Circular No. 38/2010/TT-BTC of March 19, 2010, guiding tax regulations applicable to transferors of the rights to explore, exploit and process minerals; the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 12/2010/QD-TTg of February 12, 2010, extending enterprise income tax payment time limit to further solve difficulties for enterprises and promote 2010 economic development; and the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 39/2010/TT-BTC of March 22, 2010, guiding Decision No. 12/2010/QD-TTg of February 12, 2010; Circular No. 40/2010/TT-BTC of March 23, 2010, guiding the determination of taxable incomes for differences resulted from asset revaluation; and Circular No. 55/2010/TT-BTC of April 16, 2010, guiding value-added tax and enterprise income tax for Vietnam Television and television and radio-television stations of provinces and cities.

Tax obligations of foreign organizations and individuals doing business or earning incomes in Vietnam comply with the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 197/2009/TT-BTC of October 9, 2009, supplementing Circular No. 134/2008/TT-BTC of December 31, 2008, guiding tax obligations of foreign organizations and individuals doing business or earning incomes in Vietnam; the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 64/2010/TT-BTC of April 22, 2010, amending and supplementing Circular No. 134/2008/TT-BTC of December 31, 2008, guiding tax obligations of foreign organizations and individuals doing business or earning incomes in Vietnam.

Tax obligations of Vietnamese investors making overseas investment comply with the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 11/2010/TT-BTC of January 19, 2010, guiding the fulfillment of tax obligations by Vietnamese investors making overseas investment.

b/ Royalty: To be calculated and estimated under the National Assembly’s November 25, 2009 Law No. 45/2009/QH12 on Royalty, the National Assembly Standing Committee’s Resolution No. 928/2010/UBTVQH12, promulgating the royalty tariff; the Government’s Decree No. 50/2010/ND-CP of May 14, 2010, detailing and guiding a number of articles of the Law on Royalty; and the Finance Ministry’s Decision No. 588/QD-BTC of March 22, 2010, announcing the average sale price of commercial electricity used for calculation of royalty on natural water resource for hydro-power generation in 2010.

c/ Personal income tax: To comply with the Ministry of Finance’s documents such as Circular No. 161/2009/TT-BTC of August 12, 2009, guiding personal income tax for transfer and receipt as inheritance or gift of real estate; Circular No. 164/2009/TT-BTC of August 13, 2009, guiding personal income tax for winners of prize-winning games; Circular No. 176/2009/TT-BTC of September 9, 2009, guiding the reduction of personal income tax for individuals working in economic zones; Circular No. 02/2010/TT-BTC of January 11, 2010, additionally guiding Circular No. 84/2008/TT-BTC of September 30, 2008, guiding a number of articles of the Law on Personal Income Tax and the Government’s Decree No. 100/2008/ND-CP of September 8, 2008, detailing a number of articles of the Law on Personal Income Tax.

d/ Registration fees: To comply with the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 68/2010/TT-BTC of April 26, 2010, guiding registration fees.

e/ Oil and gas revenues: To comply with the Government’s Decree No. 100/2009/ND-CP of November 3, 3009, on surcharges for profit oil shared to oil and gas contractors upon crude oil price increase; and the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 22/2010/TT-BTC of February 12, 2010, guiding the Government’s Decree No. 100/2009/ND-CP of November 3, 3009.

Collection of regulating revenues from Dung Quat oil refinery complies with the Ministry of Finance’s separate guidance.

f/ Agricultural land use tax: To temporarily calculate and estimate revenues of this tax under current mechanisms applicable in 2003-2010.

g/ Charges and fees: To comply with the Ordinance on Charges and Fees and current legal documents. For consular charges and fees, to comply with the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 236/2009/TT-BTC of December 15, 2009, guiding regimes on collection, remittance, management and use consular charges and fees applicable to overseas Vietnamese diplomatic missions and consular offices. Environmental protection charges for mining comply with the Government’s Decree No. 82/2009/ND-CP of October 12, 2009, amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Government’s Decree No. 63/2008/ND-CP of May 13, 2008, on environmental protection charges for mining and the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 238/2009/TT-BTC of December 21, 2009, guiding the Government’s Decree No. 82/2009/ND-CP of October 12, 2009. For charges for transfer of the right to operate airports, to comply with the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 240/2009/TT-BTC of December 25, 2009.

h/ Land use levy revenues: To be estimated in conformity with the implementation of approved land use master plans (under the Government’s Decree No. 69/2009/ND-CP of August 13, 2009, additionally providing land use planning, land prices and recovery, compensation, support and resettlement) and expected schedules for land use right auction, land allotment and payment of land use levies.

i/ Lottery revenues: To be estimated under current law and collected through the state budget (not included in the state budget).

2. Export-import revenue estimates:

a/ Export-import revenues shall be estimated based on the evaluation of impacts on budget revenues by analyzing and forecasting world economic situations and export-import values of taxable goods; impacts of the adjustment of tariff and non-tariff barriers to restrain trade deficit and boost exports, and implementation of the tax reduction roadmap under international economic integration commitments.

b/ Revenues shall be estimated on the basis of complying with regulations on customs procedures, customs inspection and control, import duty and export duty and tax administration for exports and imports under the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 79/2009/TT-BTC of April 20, 2009, and relevant documents. To further simplify customs administrative procedures to shorten customs clearance time and reduce expenses for exports and imports. To increase anti-loss measures such as tax debt settlement and fight against smuggling, tax evasion and trade frauds.

3. Revenues retained for spending under regulations (school fees, hospital fees, contributions): Ministries, central agencies and localities shall estimate revenues appropriately and actively based on 2009 collected revenues, 2010 estimated revenues, expected adjustment of revenues (with collection of school fees complying with the Government’s Decree No. 49/2010/ND-CP of May 14, 2010, on school fee exemption and reduction and support of learning expenses and regimes on collection and use of school fees for educational institutions within  the national education system from school years 2010-2011 to 2014-2015) and factors likely to affect 2011 revenues. Non-business revenues from the commercial provision of services of agencies and units which do not belong to the state budget shall be estimated separately and not be included in estimates for charge and fee revenues of the state budget.

Article 10. The 2011 state budget spending estimation

1. The 2011 development investment spending estimation:

a/ 2011 development investment spending of ministries and central agencies shall be estimated on the basis of ensuring funds for ongoing works and projects; allocating sufficient funds for group-C projects to be completed within 3 years and group-B projects to be completed within 5 years; restricting funds for new projects which are not truly necessary. Development investment spending of provinces and centrally run cities shall be estimated on the basis of criteria and norms on allocation of 2011 state budget funds for development investment, including targeted additional funds for development investment from the central to local budgets and other targeted additional funds under the Prime Minister’s decisions.

b/ When estimating 2011 development investment spending, units should thoroughly grasp the view of reviewing, rearranging and readjusting investment fund allocations to raise the efficiency of state budget funds, contributing to stabilizing the macro-economy and promoting quick and sustainable economic growth. To concentrate development investment funds to achieve 2011 and 2011-2015 socio-economic development objectives, prioritizing budget allocations for national key projects and works, agricultural and rural development, promotion of poverty reduction and sustainable development; and further prioritizing development investment funds for human resource development in education and training, healthcare, science and technology, environmental protection, security and defense.

c/ To prioritize funds to implement social security policies; to allocate sufficient domestic funds for ODA-funded programs and projects under commitments; to concentrate funds on ongoing efficient works and projects, key and urgent works being dikes, irrigation, rural roads, flood division and obstruction infrastructure and tourism infrastructure.

d/ To ensure funds for investment preparation; to pay debts of completed capital construction volumes; to refund advanced amounts under regulations; concurrently to prevent new capital construction debts.

e/ To allocate remaining funds to new projects and works, prioritizing national key projects and works; to determinedly suspend construction of projects outside approved master plans, with incomplete formalities under regulations, having investment formality problems or having not cleared construction site, and non-urgent or inefficient projects.

f/ Investors of projects funded by foreign loans borrowed by the Government shall arrange sufficient domestic funds for these projects in accordance with signed lending agreements and the Regulation on domestic financial management not to affect implementation schedules.

g/ Spending for making up interest rate differences of development investment credit and credit under state policies shall be estimated under regulations based on 2010 implementation results, expected changes in policies and 2011 tasks.

h/ For estimates of additional spending from state reserves: Based on the national reserves development strategy, state-assigned reserve tasks, requirements for prevention and remedy of natural disasters and epidemics, ministries and branches managing state reserve goods shall evaluate and determine state reserves under their management up to December 31, 2010; estimate additional reserves for each type of completely essential goods and supplies, estimate state budget spending for state reserves increases, good preservation and plans on rotation and renewal of state reserves goods in 2011.

i/ To add targeted development investment funds from the central budget according to criteria and norms on allocation of development investment spending estimates from 2011 state budget decided by the Prime Minister to implement national target programs, national programs in 2011-2015, the program on quick and sustainable poverty reduction for 62 poor districts and other major programs and projects to be implemented in 2011-2015; support of part of domestic funds for ODA-funded projects; support localities in investment in industrial park infrastructure and provincial-level healthcare system, prioritizing additional funds for local budgets in northern midland and mountainous regions, northern central and coastal central regions, the Central Highlands, the southwestern region, and difficulty-hit ethnic minority areas and localities.

j/ Ministries, central agencies and localities assigned by the Prime Minister to invest in capital construction with government bond funds shall estimate 2011 government bond funds to be invested in works and projects on transport, irrigation, healthcare establishment system, school consolidation and building of public-duty houses for teachers and houses for students already on the list approved by competent authorities. Concurrently to direct timely implementation according to set objectives.

2. The 2011 regular spending estimation:

a/ Estimation of spending on development of education and training, culture, healthcare, environmental protection, and science and technology, social security, defense and security; and spending on state, party and mass organization administration shall be based on political tasks and 2011 socio-economic development plans of each ministry, central agency and locality and norms on allocation of 2011 state budget regular spending under the Prime Minister’s decision and specific regimes and policies promulgated by competent authorities.

b/ 2011 regular expenditures without allocation norms shall be estimated on the basis of evaluating the 2010 budget implementation, expected 2011 tasks (specifying expenditures arising only in 2010, not in 2011, increased expenditures arising in 2011 according to regimes and domains approved by competent authorities), notified examination codes of 2011 budget and spending regimes, criteria and norms under current regulations. Priority should be given to the allocation of funds to implement promulgated spending regimes and policies and to perform import tasks assigned by the Prime Minister or competent authorities to each branch and domain.

c/ To allocate 20% of 2011 total state budget spending estimates (including development investment spending, regular spending and spending on wage reforms and spending from lottery revenues) for education, training and vocational training; at least 1.8%, for culture and communications; at least 2%, for science and technology; and over 1%, for environmental protection. To increase rate spending for healthcare at a rate higher than the average state budget spending increase, prioritizing funds for preventive medicine.

d/ To estimate spending on construction economy based on the volume of work assigned by competent authorities and budget spending regimes and norms; to concentrate funds on important tasks such as upgrading and maintaining essential economic infrastructure (transport, irrigation) to increase use time and investment efficiency; funds for planning work, agricultural, forestry, fishery and industrial extension, cadastral map measuring, compilation of cadastral dossiers and grant of land use right certificates to promote economic growth and restructuring. To increasingly apply the regulation on bidding, order placement and task assignment for the state budget-funded provision of public non-business services under the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 39/2008/QD-TTg of March 14, 2008.

e/ When estimating the 2011 state budget, ministries, branches and localities shall restructure state budget spending tasks appropriately on the basis of autonomy in and accountability for use of payrolls and administration funds under the Government’s Decree No. 130/2005/ND-CP of October 17, 2005, in order to increase autonomy associated with accountability, improve financial management effectiveness and operation efficiency. Public non-business units shall comply with the Government’s Decree No. 43/2006/ND-CP of April 25, 2006, on autonomy in and accountability for task performance and organization of apparatus, payrolls and finance for public non-business units, and Decree No. 115/2005/ND-CP of September 5, 2005, and other relevant regulations on autonomy and accountability of public science and technology institutions; to concurrently transform a number of eligible public non-business units into enterprises on a trial basis.

f/ State administrative agencies and public non-business units generating incomes under law shall fully estimate revenues and expenditures for their tasks from charge, fee and other revenues retained at their units for spending under regulations.

g/ Units shall estimate budget spending for scientific research, state-ordered tasks and other important tasks under current regulations and this Circular, fully explaining grounds for estimation.

h/ For some other particular spending tasks:

- Ministries and central agencies with secondment sections merged into Vietnamese representative missions overseas shall make estimates to ensure funds for the operation of those sections and send them to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for incorporation into the latter’s estimates and submission to competent authorities for allocation to Vietnamese representative missions overseas under the Prime Minister’s Directive No. 367/CT-TTg of March 19, 2010.

- Spending on information technology application shall be estimated under the Government’s Decree No. 64/2007/ND-CP of April 10, 2007, on information technology application to the operation of state agencies, and May 26, 2008 Joint Circular No. 43/2008/TTLT-BTC-BTTTT of the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Information and Communications.

- To estimate necessary funds to implement the Program on law dissemination and education in 2008-2012 approved by the Prime Minister under Decision No. 37/2008/QD-TTg of March 12, 2008.

- To estimate funds to implement the Scheme on comprehensive renewal of statistical indicator systems within the tasks of ministries and central agencies under the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 312/QD-TTg of March 2, 2010.

- To estimate state budget spending to implement mechanisms on school fee exemption and reduction and learning expense support for beneficiaries specified in the Government’s Decree No. 49/2010/ND-CP of May 14, 2010, on school fee exemption and reduction and learning expense support and regimes on school fee collection and use for educational institutions within the national education system from school years 2010-2011 to 2014-2015.

3. Estimation of spending on ODA-funded programs and projects:

To fully estimate spending according to the order and forms of state budget estimation and decision under the State Budget Law, the Law on Public Debt Management and their guiding documents, government decrees on investment and capital construction management, foreign loan borrowing and payment, paying attention to detailing ODA and domestic funds by each program and project and funding source for capital construction investment and non-business spending, ensuring conformity with implementation schedules; to submit spending estimates to the Ministry of Planning and Investment and the Ministry of Finance for inclusion into 2011 state budget estimates and submission to the Government and the National Assembly for decision.

4. Estimation of funds for implementing 2011 wage reforms:

In 2011, ministries, central agencies and localities and state budget-funded units shall proactively, fully and properly implement regulations on solutions to creating funds for implementing wage reforms under the Scheme on wage reforms in 2008-2012, including part of revenues retained in 2011 under regulations; saving of 10% of 2011 regular spending (excluding salaries and amounts of salary nature); 50% of local budget increases against 2010 local budget estimates (excluding increased land use levy revenues) and the previous year’s unused funds for implementing wage reforms (if any) carried forward to 2011 for further spending. All these funds shall be accounted and managed separately to further create funds for implementing wage reforms and may not be used for other purposes. The Ministry of Finance shall provide separate guidance on the calculation and determination of funds for implementing 2011 wage reforms after the Government issues a new decree on minimum wage adjustment.

5. Estimation of spending on national target programs and important projects:

a/ Ministries and agencies managing programs and projects shall, based on competent authorities’ documents on national target programs and major programs and projects to be implemented in 2011-2015, coordinate with the Ministry of Planning and Investment in setting clear objectives and specific tasks in 2011 for national target programs and important programs and projects and submit them to the Prime Minister for decision, providing a basis for 2011 state budget estimation.

To make estimates for the national target program on economical and effective use of energy and response to climate change in 2011 and 2011-2015 under decisions approved by the Prime Minister.

b/ Based on current objectives, tasks and financial regimes, ministries, central agencies and localities shall estimate funds to implement programs and projects in 2011, and submit them to ministries and central agencies managing those programs and projects for sum-up and submission to the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Planning and Investment.

c/ Based on estimated fund allocations to each program and project notified by the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Planning and Investment, ministries and central agencies assigned to manage programs and projects shall estimate 2011 funds for each program and project; concurrently adopt plans on allocation of these funds for 2011 target programs and projects to ministries, central agencies and localities (for foreign-funded programs, plans on allocation must detail both domestic and foreign funds) and submit them to the Ministry of Planning and Investment and the Ministry of Finance for consideration and summarization.

6. State budget reserves estimation:

Reserves shall be made for central and local budgets at all levels under the State Budget Law and norms on allocation of regular state budget  spending for proactive prevention, control and consequence remedy of natural disasters and epidemics and performance of unexpected important and urgent tasks. 2011 state budget spending estimates of ministries, central agencies and local agencies and units must allocate and record in a separate section spending on search and rescue, salvage and response to natural disasters and calamities under the Prime Minister’s Decision No. 118/2008/QD-TTg of August 27, 2008, promulgating the Regulation on financial management of activities in search and rescue, salvage and response to natural disasters and calamities, and the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 92/2009/TT-BTC of May 12, 2009, guiding the payment of state budget funds for organizations’ and individuals’ activities in search, rescue and salvage and response to natural disasters and calamities.

7. Estimation of spending with revenues retained under regulations (school fees, hospital fees and contributions):

Ministries, central agencies and localities shall estimate in detail spending from this revenue source by spending task and area and incorporate them into their general estimates for submission to competent authorities for decision.

8. Based on examination codes of 2011 budget revenues and expenditures, ministries, central agencies and localities shall precisely estimate spending in detail  for each task and each state budget-funded attached unit. After working and reaching agreement with the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Planning and Investment, ministries, central agencies and provinces and centrally run cities shall promptly prepare plans to allocate their 2011 state budget estimates so as, upon receipt of budget estimates assigned by the Prime Minister, to proactively submit them to competent authorities for decision on allocation and assignment of budget estimates to budget-funded units before December 31 under the State Budget Law.

Ministries, central agencies and localities shall concentrate on reviewing all stages in state budget allocation, management and use, especially for capital construction investment funds and loans and grants, to ensure budget allocation for proper purposes, according to regimes and to proper beneficiaries. Budget funds shall be managed and used correctly and effectively and reported, examined and audited under regulations to prevent loss and wastefulness.

Article 11. The 2011 local budget estimation

2011 is the first year of the new local budget stabilization period under the State Budget Law. Localities shall estimate their revenues and expenditures for 2011 and 2011-2015 following 2011 state budget objectives and tasks mentioned above and on the basis of resources according to norms on 2011 budget allocation, the State Budget Law and its guiding documents. 2011 local budget estimation must guarantee local budget development, sufficient resources for implementation of centrally promulgated regimes and policies and compliance with the State Budget Law.

Apart from complying with general guiding regulations on state budget estimation, local budget estimation should take into account the following major contents:

1. Local budget revenue estimation:

On the basis of the objectives set in draft 2011-2015 socio-economic development plans of the country and ministries, branches and localities, the capacity to achieve 2010 socio-economic and budget targets, forecasts on 2011 economic growth and revenues of each branch, domain and economic institutions of each locality and revenues newly arising in localities, to precisely and fully calculate each area and type of revenues under regulations. Estimates of domestic revenues from taxes and charges (excluding revenues from crude oil and land use levies) will grow at least 17-19% against estimated 2010 revenues (already excluding factors caused by tax payment extension in 2009 and 2010); export-import revenue estimates, at least 7-9% against estimated 2010  revenues (already excluding factors caused by tax payment extension in 2009 and 2010).

2. Local budget spending estimation:

- Based on local state budget revenue estimates, local budget revenues wholly retained at localities under the State Budget Law, local budget spending balance according to criteria and norms on 2011 budget allocation under the Prime Minister’s decision, to determine the percentage (%) of revenues shared between central and local budgets, additional amounts balanced from central to local budgets (if any) to be stabilized in the new budget period under the State Budget Law and its guiding documents. On that basis and based on 2011-2015 socio-economic development tasks of localities and 2011 socio-economic development targets, current spending regimes and policies and realities of each locality, provincial-level Finance Departments shall coordinate with provincial-level Planning and Investment Departments in advising provincial-level People’s Committees in submitting to provincial-level People’s Councils for decision decentralization of revenue sources and spending tasks in the new budget stabilization period and norms on 2011 local budget allocation to each lower-level local administration and stabilization of additional amounts balanced from higher to lower-level budget and percentage (%) of revenues shared between budgets of local administrations of different levels for each year of the new stabilization period. To concurrently ensure norms on local budget allocation to important spending tasks (education, training and vocational training, science and technology, environment) not lower than the levels set in resolutions of the Party, decided by the National Assembly and assigned by the Prime Minister.

- To prioritize funds for building infrastructure, to concentrate investment in local key projects and works to be completed and operate soon (transport, irrigation, works for economic restructuring and natural disaster remedy); to proactively allocate local budgets for school consolidation programs, investment in canal consolidation, rural roads, craft village infrastructure and tourism; development of plant varieties and animal breeds; economic restructuring; trade promotion, export market expansion and search; to attach importance to implementing social security tasks such as poverty reduction, and employment.

- To allocate domestic funds for ODA-funded projects in localities falling within localities’ responsibility under the Prime Minister’s decisions; to proactively calculate and allocate source capital construction investment spending estimates to completely settle capital construction debts and other due debts.

- To allocate capital construction investment spending estimates of local budgets from land use levy revenues for investment in socio-economic infrastructure works, projects on relocation, resettlement and preparation of construction sites; to proactively allocate and set aside funds for land development under the Government’s Decree No. 69/2009/ND-CP of August 13, 2009; to prioritize sufficient funds to accelerate the measuring and formation of a cadastral database and grant of land use right certificates under the Land Law and resolutions of the National Assembly.

- To continue using lottery revenues for investment in social welfare works, concentrating on education and healthcare under regulations and managing revenues and expenditures through the state budget (not included in the state budget).

- To adopt plans to raise funds for investment in local infrastructure, to allocate local budgets to fully pay due debts (both principal and interest) under Clause 3, Article 8 of the State Budget Law and the Government’s Decree No. 60/2003/ND-CP of June 6, 2003, ensuring balance of raised funds (including the amount expected for the year) not exceeding 30% of provincial-level capital construction investment spending estimates (for Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City, not exceeding 100%).

- To prioritize funds to implement promulgated socio-economic development policies under resolutions of the Party, the National Assembly and the Prime Minister’s decisions.

- When estimating 2011 budget spending, localities shall proactively calculate revenue sources for spending on wage reforms under Clause 4 of Article 10 above.

3. For local administrations at the levels that do not organize People’s Councils on a pilot basis, 2011 budget estimation complies with this Circular. The estimation process and time comply with the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 63/2009/TT-BTC of March 27, 2009, on estimation, implementation and settlement of budgets of urban and rural districts and wards which do not organize People’s Councils.

Chapter III

ORGANIZATION OF IMPLEMENTATION

Article 12. Responsibilities of ministries and central agencies managing national target programs, Program 135 and national key programs and projects

1. To coordinate with concerned ministries, central agencies and localities in planning tasks and estimating funds for 2011 programs and projects and submit them to the Ministry of Planning and Investment and the Ministry of Finance before July 20, 2010.

2. To work out plans on allocation of 2011 spending estimates for each ministry, central agency and province or centrally run city and submit them to the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Planning and Investment before July 30, 2010.

3. To proactively elaborate, promulgate and complete guiding documents under their competence to be completed in 2010 to provide a basis for implementing programs and projects from 2011 under regulations.

Article 13. Responsibilities of ministries, central agencies and localities:

1. Based on notified examination codes, ministries, central agencies and provincial-level People’s Committees shall guide and notify examination codes for budget revenue and spending estimates to their attached estimating units and lower level budgets under regulations.

2. The Ministry of Planning and Investment shall assume the prime responsibility for, and coordinate with the Ministry of Finance in, estimating development investment funds and adopting plans to allocate central budget funds for investment development of some assigned domains and submit them to the Ministry of Finance before September 10, 2010.

3. To make, review and report on 2011 budget estimates under the State Budget Law, its guiding documents and this Circular; to make reports with full contents and forms under the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 59/2003/TT-BTC of June 23, 2003, and relevant forms under this Circular; and submit them to the Ministry of Finance and the State Audit of Vietnam before July 20, 2010, for ministries and central agencies, and before July 25, 2010, for provinces and centrally run cities.

Article 14. The 2011 budget estimation forms and reports

1. For ministries and central agencies: To summarize and report to the Ministry of Finance state budget estimates according to the forms and deadlines under the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 59/2003/TT-BTC of June 23, 2003, additional forms (Forms No. 2 and 5) under this Circular (not printed herein) and the forms under Joint Circular No. 03/2006/TTLT-BTC-BNV of January 17, 2006 of the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Home Affairs, guiding the Government’s Decree No. 130/2005/ND-CP of October 17, 2005, the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 71/2006/TT-BTC of August 9, 2006, guiding Decree No. 43/2006/ND-CP; paying attention to detail budget estimates for each budget-funded unit (according to Form No. 02, Appendix 2 to Circular No. 59/2003/TT-BTC) and important tasks of ministries and agencies for explanation and reporting to the National Assembly on budget estimates of each ministry and central agency. After the Prime Minister’s assignment of 2011 budget estimates, to allocate and assign budget estimates to budget-funded units before December 31, 2010 under the State Budget Law.

2. For localities: To summarize and report to the Ministry of Finance local budget estimates according to the forms (Forms No. 01, 02, 06, 07, 10, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22 and 23, Appendix 6) and deadlines specified in the Finance Ministry’s Circular No. 59/2002003/TT-BTC of June 23, 2003, and additional forms (Forms No. 01, 03, 04, 06, 07, 08, 09, 10 and 11) under this Circular (not printed herein).

Article 15. Implementation provisions

1. This Circular takes effect on the date of its signing.

2. In the course of 2011 budget estimation, the Ministry of Finance shall provide additional guidance on new policies and regimes. Ministries, central agencies, localities and state economic groups and corporations are requested to report on problems arising in their 2011 budget estimation to the Ministry of Finance for prompt settlement.-

For the Minister of Finance
Deputy Minister
DO HOANG ANH TUAN